Measure to optimise.

Fundamentals of resistance spot welding, nugget quality and statistical control, and how to put it all into practice in Weldia.

Q = I²Rt
heat grows with the square of the current
≥ 1.33
target Cpl for a capable spot weld, with margin
3
root cause categories: design, parameters, dynamics
4·√t
rule of thumb for the minimum nugget diameter

Sections

Everything you need to weld and measure better.

By role

Choose your path.

TECHNICIAN

Measurement technician

Runs measurement sessions on the shop floor.

QUALITY_ENGINEER

Quality engineer

Follows SPC, alerts and capability.

PROCESS_ENGINEER

Process engineer

Manages weld spots, parameters and guns; analyses opportunities.

VIEWER · ADMIN

Management and administration

Consults indicators and manages the organisation.

Improvement cycle

From opportunity to validation measurement.

Weldia turns measurements into signals of stability, risk and gain. The goal is to close the loop between quality and process.

See opportunities
01 Opportunity → stable, capable spot weld
02 Simulation → predict nugget and energy
03 WeldParameter → new DRAFT version
04 Approval → UNDER_REVIEW → APPROVED
05 Measurement → confirm Cpl ≥ 1.33

Getting started

How to use this wiki

The wiki is organised in three layers: the technical fundamentals, quality and defects, and use of the platform. Each technical concept points to the place in Weldia where it applies.

Structure

SectionWhat forKey pages
FundamentalsUnderstand why a spot weld turns out well or badlyPrinciple, Cycle, Eight factors
Quality and defectsDiagnose and prevent problemsProcess window, Common problems, Root cause
Weldia in practiceUse the platform day to daySessions, SPC Cockpit, Opportunities
ReferenceLook up standards, terms and sourcesISO standards, Glossary, Frequently asked questions

Conventions

In Weldia

Blue boxes link the concept to the screen, field or rule of the platform.

Caution

Amber boxes flag common mistakes or quality risks.

Good practice

Green boxes summarise the recommendation to apply.

  • Platform field names, statuses and rules appear in monospace: NEEDS_REVIEW, CPL_BELOW_1_33.
  • Technical terms give common synonyms in brackets on first occurrence: expulsion (splash).
  • The figures are illustrative: they show qualitative trends, not data from a real line.

Wiki shortcuts

KeyAction
/Go to search
↑ ↓ EnterNavigate the search results
EscClose the search or the menu

Content source

The full technical content is in the file docs/wiki/conhecimento-soldadura-resistencia.en.md, and the figures in docs/wiki/images/en/. To update a figure, edit docs/wiki/tools/gerar_imagens.py and regenerate them.

Fundamentals

Principle of resistance welding

No arc and no filler material: a high current passes through the sheets clamped between two electrodes, and the electrical resistance locally melts the metal at the interface.

Cross-section of a spot weld: copper electrodes, two sheets, molten nugget at the interface, force and current
Fig. 1The electrodes apply the force F and carry the current I; the nugget forms at the interface between the sheets.

Joule's law

Q = I² · R · theat [J] = current² [A²] × resistance [Ω] × time [s]
SymbolMeaningOrder of magnitude in car bodies
IWelding current (RMS)6 – 14 kA in steel; > 20 kA in aluminium
RTotal resistance along the pathtens to hundreds of µΩ
tCurrent flow time100 – 600 ms
  • Current counts squared. +10 % current gives about +21 % heat. It is the most sensitive parameter.
  • The heat has to originate at the interface. Design and parameters exist to concentrate the heat where the nugget is wanted.
  • Heat is also lost. The electrodes are water-cooled; below a minimum current, more time does not form a weld.

The role of force

Force is applied before the current, to ensure contact; during it, to contain the molten metal; and after it, to forge the nugget as it solidifies.

Resistances in series

Seven resistances in series: electrodes, sheets and three contacts
Fig. 2The sheet/sheet contact resistance (R4) is where the nugget originates.
  • Contact resistances (R2, R4, R6): dominate the first milliseconds and decrease with pressure and temperature.
  • Material resistance (R3, R5): increases with temperature.
  • Dynamic resistance: the R(t) curve that results from the two. It is the signal most used in real-time monitoring.
In Weldia

The result that is measured is the nugget diameter, recorded in each NuggetMeasurement and compared with the minimum diameter of the WeldSpot.

Fundamentals

Process families

Resistance welding processes differ in how they concentrate the heat: through the electrode, through the part or through an additional element.

Three families: heating through the electrode, through the part and with an additional element
Fig. 3Families A, B and C.
FamilyHow the heat is concentratedExamples
A, through the electrodeShape of the electrode tipSpot (RSW), single-sided, series, indirect, seam, parallel gap
B, through the partProjections, embossments or the natural shape of the partsProjection, nuts and studs, cross wire, butt, battery terminals
C, with an elementElement between the partsElement welding, brazing, weld bonding, soldering

Spot welding

It is the dominant process in car body assembly (body-in-white): a typical car has between 3,000 and 6,000 spot welds. The shape of the electrode tip defines the contact area and, with it, the size of the nugget.

Projection

The projection must concentrate the current without collapsing too quickly. As a rule, it goes on the part that has more difficulty heating up: the thicker one, if the materials are the same, or the one with lower resistivity, if they differ. Fast electrode follow-up is critical, because the projection collapses within milliseconds.

In Weldia

The platform focuses on family A, spot welding with robotic guns.

Fundamentals

Weld cycle and weld schedule

Each spot weld is made according to a weld schedule with well-defined phases. In Weldia, that schedule is stored and versioned in WeldParameter.

Current and force profile across the phases of the cycle
Fig. 4Two-pulse weld schedule: the force is held from squeeze to the end of hold.

Phases

PhaseFieldFunctionToo shortToo long
SqueezesqueezeClose and stabilise the forceInitial expulsionLost cycle time
Pulse 1weld1Preheating, coating, gaps—Surface overheating
Cool 1cool1Pause between pulses——
Pulse 2weld2Nugget growthCold weldExpulsion, wear, indentation
Cool 2cool2Optional pause——
HoldholdSolidify under forcePorosity, cracks, LMEBrittle nugget in hardenable steels
ForceforceContact and forgingExpulsionLess heat, indentation
StepperstepperCompensate for electrode wearNugget shrinksExpulsion at end of life
Units

On AC machines times are often given in mains cycles (1 cycle = 20 ms at 50 Hz). On MFDC they are given in ms. Check the unit before comparing weld schedules.

Current types

AC, three-phase DC, MFDC and capacitor discharge waveforms
Fig. 5Typical waveforms.
TypeCharacteristicsUse
Single-phase AC50/60 Hz, conduction angleOlder installations
Three-phase DCReduced rippleLarge guns, aluminium
MFDC~1 kHz, fast response, compact transformerStandard in automotive robotics
Capacitor dischargeShort, intense peakMicro-welding, conductors

Fundamentals

The eight influencing factors

More than a hundred variables have been identified in the literature. In practice, they group into eight factors, and diagnosis works through them.

#FactorMain effectTypical sign
1CurrentHeat ∝ I²; the nugget grows quickly up to expulsionExpulsion (high) · cold weld (low)
2TimeHeat ∝ t; below the minimum current it is not enoughElectrode sticking with long times
3ForceDefines the contact: too little → expulsion; too much → less heatIndentation, initial expulsion
4Contact resistanceDecides where the heat originates in the first cyclesBatch-to-batch variation, oil, oxides
5MaterialResistivity generates heat; conductivity dissipates itChange of supplier
6CoatingsZinc, AlSi: contact and electrode contaminationAccelerated wear
7GeometryTip, thicknesses, no. of sheets, edge, pitchOff-centre nugget, shunting
8MachineCurrent rise, inductive losses, stiffness, follow-upDifferences between "identical" guns
In Weldia

Factors 1–3 → WeldParameter. Factors 5–7 → WeldSpot (sheet stack, thicknesses, minimum diameter) and GunConfiguration (electrode, tip dressing, maximum force). Factor 8 → robot and gun in the hierarchy.

Contact resistance in detail

All surfaces are rough at the microscopic scale. With more force, the asperities flatten, the real contact area increases and the resistance drops. With temperature, contaminants (water, oil) burn off and the metal softens, and the resistance also drops. Although it only dominates in the first cycles, it defines the initial heat distribution and, with it, where the nugget starts.

Machine characteristics

  • Electrical: current rise time and inductive losses, which grow with the gun's throat opening and the steel inside the window.
  • Mechanical: arm stiffness and electrode follow-up speed. Slow follow-up causes expulsion, especially in projection welding.

Fundamentals

Materials and weldability

Weldability is the ease with which a combination of materials and thicknesses produces good spot welds within a window wide enough for stable production.

General rule: metals with high resistivity and low thermal conductivity weld better.

MaterialBehaviourPrecautions
Low-carbon steelVery good weldabilityReference
AHSS (DP, TRIP, MS, PHS)Heats more; narrower window; expulsion at lower currentsHigher force, multi-pulse, suitable hold
Galvanised (GI, GA)The zinc melts and alloys with the copperMore force and current; dress more often; LME risk
AlSi (hot stamping)The coating becomes more resistive in the furnaceAdjust current; watch the projections
AluminiumLow resistivity, high conductivity, oxideVery high current, short time, cooling, cleaning
CopperGenerates little heat and dissipates it quicklyProjection, brazing, tungsten electrodes

Heat balance

Comparison between two identical sheets and a three-sheet combination
Fig. 6With different thicknesses and resistivities, the heat shifts towards the thick, resistive sheets.
  • The thicker sheet and the more resistive sheet heat up more.
  • Thickness ratio (total ÷ thinnest): as a rule of thumb, up to 3:1 to 4:1.
  • Three sheets with a thin, soft outer sheet is the most critical case in the car body.
  • Solutions: electrodes of different diameters, pre-pulse, multi-pulse, ramped current, or revising the design.

Minimum diameter

d_min ≈ 4·√t d_nominal ≈ 5·√tt = thickness of the thinnest sheet [mm]; rule of thumb used in manufacturer standards and in ISO 18278-2
t (mm)0.71.01.21.52.0
4·√t (mm)3.34.04.44.95.7
5·√t (mm)4.25.05.56.17.1
In Weldia

The minimum diameter is an attribute of each WeldSpot and is the LSL used throughout SPC. When the material or the supplier changes, review weldability before assuming the old weld schedule.

Fundamentals

Electrodes and tip dressing

The electrode is the component that changes most during production. With wear, the face widens, the current density drops and the nugget shrinks.

New and worn tip; stepped current and tip dressing over the electrode life
Fig. 7The stepper raises the current in steps; tip dressing periodically restores the geometry.

Mechanisms

  • Geometric: the face widens (mushrooming), forms craters (pitting) or loses material. Typical with galvanised steel.
  • Metallurgical: the copper alloys with zinc or aluminium, recrystallises and softens. With aluminium this happens very quickly.

Electrode life ends when the minimum diameter can no longer be reached. In the lobe, wear shifts the window towards higher currents.

Compensation

MethodHow it worksIn Weldia
Stepped currentRaises the current in steps every N spot weldsstepper in the WeldParameter
Tip dressingRestores the geometry and cleans the face every N spot weldsGunMillingProgram 241 / 242 / 250
Adaptive controlAdjusts the current from the dynamic resistanceFuture device integration
Good practice

A sawtooth measurement series (drops and recovers) synchronised with tip dressing is normal. A continuous decline with no recovery indicates failed tip dressing, insufficient stepper or poor cooling.

Standards

Cap geometry is in ISO 5821 (for example, F shapes with 16 and 20 mm faces, such as the references FF16A00 and FF20A00 in GunConfiguration). Electrode materials are in ISO 5182 (CuCr1Zr, CuCo2Be, …).

Quality and defects

Process window

The nugget is hidden between the sheets and cannot be inspected visually. Quality is ensured by working within a known parameter window.

Growth curve

Only the current varies, with force and time fixed. It is useful when force and time are already defined.

Nugget diameter as a function of current, with the window between the minimum current and expulsion
Fig. 8The current window runs from the minimum diameter up to expulsion.

Weldability lobe

It maps two variables, current × time or current × force, and gives a more complete view of the process (ISO 14327).

Weldability lobe between the minimum diameter boundary and the expulsion boundary
Fig. 9The working point sits near the expulsion limit, with margin.

How to choose the working point

  1. Stay inside the lobe. Outside it there are cold welds or expulsions.
  2. Prefer the expulsion side, with margin. Wear and other disturbances reduce the nugget over time. Starting near the upper limit gives more headroom to the lower one.
  3. Keep a margin to expulsion (typically 0.5 – 1 kA in steel), and more if there are gaps or misalignments.
  4. Higher force widens the lobe, but shortens electrode life and increases indentation.
  5. Stronger steels have the expulsion limit at lower currents.
In Weldia

SPC shows when a weld spot leaves the window on the low side (mean falling, Cpl dropping). Opportunities show weld spots with margin to reduce time or energy without leaving it.

Quality and defects

Defects and failures

Defects fall into three classes, and the class already points to the likely cause.

Three classes of defects: material, nugget and external
Fig. 10Classification of defects and failures.
ClassDominant causeWhere to act
Material defectsMaterials and coatings at critical temperature and stressChoice of materials; hold and multi-pulse
Nugget failuresParameter settingWeld schedule optimisation
External failuresExcess heat or forceReduce energy, adjust force and fixturing

Acceptance criterion

In the peel test or the chisel test (ISO 10447), a good spot weld fails with full button pull-out (full plug). Interfacial fracture generally indicates an insufficient weld, although in ultra-high-strength steels it should be assessed case by case.

Recording a defect in Weldia

  1. Measure the diameter of the pulled-out button and enter it in the session task.
  2. If it is below the minimum, the platform asks for an explicit decision: keep MEASURED or change to NEEDS_REVIEW.
  3. To flag for review in any case, use the R key.
  4. Saving creates a new revision and queues the SPC recalculation for the weld spot.

Quality and defects

Common problems in production

Cold weld, expulsion, gaps and misalignment: the most common causes, how to recognise them and how to reduce them.

Cold weld / stuck weld

No nugget of sufficient size forms, or it forms at only one of the interfaces. It is one of the most serious problems in multi-sheet stacks.

CauseExampleAction
Poor contactElectrode poorly seated, gapEnsure contact, close the gap during squeeze
Poor parametersLow current, short time, large faceOptimise current/time/force; dress the tips
Heat balanceHigh ratio, different resistivitiesDifferent electrodes, pre-pulse, multi-pulse

Expulsion / spatter

Molten metal is ejected from the nugget. It causes defects, cosmetic problems, risks to operators, dirt on the line and wasted energy.

  • Parameters: high current, long time, low force.
  • Small contact: unevenly worn face, misaligned electrodes.
  • Surface: dirt, oxides, anything that increases the surface resistance.
  • Gap between sheets.
Signal

Frequent expulsions indicate a process too close to the upper limit of the window. Lowering the current blindly, however, pushes the process towards the lower limit: check the electrode and the gap first.

Gap between sheets

Unclosed gap with expulsion versus gap closed before the current
Fig. 11The gap has to close before the current flows.
  • It comes from stamping or fixturing tolerances.
  • It shifts the expulsion limit to lower currents and narrows the lobe.
  • Robust strategy: parameters in the zone common to the lobes of the expected gaps (0, 0.2, 0.5 mm…).
  • Direct solutions: longer squeeze, more squeeze force, low-current pre-pulse.

Electrode misalignment

It results from assembly errors or from the elastic deflection of the gun: the electrodes end up tilted or with offset centres. The nugget becomes irregular and there are expulsions. Checking the gun's squareness is part of preventive maintenance.

Hot-stamped parts

22MnB5 parts with AlSi arrive with a transformed coating of higher resistance and with very high hardness. Changes in the furnace later show up as variations in welding. On projection nuts, the difference in hardness can make the projection collapse before the weld forms.

See also: Shunting effect · LME.

Quality and defects

Shunting effect

Part of the current is diverted through nearby spot welds that have already been made. The new spot weld receives less current and turns out smaller.

Top view with an existing spot weld, a new spot weld and the shunt current between them
Fig. 12The shunt current is greatest at the start of the pulse.
FactorEffect on shunting
Smaller pitch↑ strong, the most influential factor
More spot welds already made↑ cumulative along a row
Thicker sheets↑ less resistive lateral path
Mild steel↑ compared with high-strength steels
Start of the pulse↑ the new contact is still very resistive

In a row of spot welds, the diameter reduction can accumulate to 20–30 % at the last spot weld, and the nuggets lean towards their neighbours. In a three-sheet combination, the interface with mild steel is the most affected.

Mitigation

Respect the minimum pitch, order the welding sequence and compensate the current of the spot welds in sequence.

In Weldia

Weld spots in the same cell with systematically smaller diameters in a dense zone (Drilldown and Equipment tabs) are shunting candidates. Compare with the sequenceNo and the X/Y/Z coordinates.

Quality and defects

Liquid metal embrittlement (LME)

Cracking of zinc-coated high-strength steels, when liquid zinc penetrates the grain boundaries under stress.

Cross-section with the LME-sensitive zones at the shoulder of the indentation
Fig. 13The shoulder of the indentation cools poorly and is left in tension.

Three simultaneous conditions

  1. Temperature in the steel's low-ductility range.
  2. Local tensile stress, which increases with the heat input and with abrupt cooling.
  3. Liquid zinc in contact with the steel.

How to reduce it

  • Avoid excess heat, especially near expulsion.
  • Multi-pulse to reduce stress peaks, or a pre-pulse to push the zinc away.
  • Electrodes without sharp edges in the contact zone.
  • Sufficient hold for the zinc to solidify before the electrodes open.
Caution

Automotive industry studies (WorldAutoSteel) indicate that relevant LME cracks appear mainly when there are deviations from the correct parameter and assembly conditions. A process well centred in the window is the first line of defence.

Quality and defects

Root cause analysis

All root causes fit into three categories. Investigate in this order: a design problem cannot be solved with parameters.

Design, parameter setting and dynamics
Fig. 14Three root cause categories.
CategoryKey questionTypical SPC pattern
1 · DesignDoes the heat concentrate at the right interface?Low Cpl from the start, on every gun with that combination
2 · Parameter settingIs the working point centred in the window?Stable mean but close to the LSL; CPL_BELOW_1_33
3 · DynamicsDid something change during production?DOWNWARD_TREND_6, SAME_SIDE_BELOW_MEAN_8, BELOW_LCL

Checklist when a weld spot goes into alert

  1. Confirm the measurement: method, operator, previous revision.
  2. Isolated or grouped? See the Equipment tab: weld spot, gun, robot, cell or tag.
  3. Grouped by gun: electrode, tip dressing, alignment, cooling.
  4. Grouped by product/tag: material batch, stamping, gaps.
  5. Isolated but persistent: parameter setting of that weld spot (window, shunting, edge).
  6. Record and act: if you change parameters, create a DRAFT version for approval and measure to validate.

Quick diagnosis table

SymptomLikely causesFirst check
Diameter falling graduallyElectrode wear, insufficient stepperSpot weld counter and last tip dressing
Sudden drop on one gunFailed tip dressing, cap changed, coolingFace condition and water flow
Drop across a whole productMaterial batch, coating, stampingBatch certificate, supplier
High scatter, good meanGaps, misalignment, unstable contactFixturing and gun squareness
Smaller spot welds in a dense zoneShuntingPitch and sequence
Expulsions and irregular diameterHigh current, low force, gapApproved vs. executed weld schedule

Quality and defects

Quality beyond diameter

A spot weld can meet the minimum diameter and still be bad: with expulsion, excessive indentation, insufficient fusion or degraded metallurgy.

Radar chart with six quality factors for two weld schedules
Fig. 15Two weld schedules with a similar nugget and different overall quality.
FactorWhat it measuresWhy it matters
ExpulsionStabilityDefects, safety, energy
DiameterSize of the fused zoneStrength
PenetrationFusion into each sheetCritical in 3-sheet stacks
IndentationSurface deformationAppearance, fatigue
LME riskSusceptibility to crackingDurability in AHSS
HAZ softeningDrop in hardnessLoad-bearing capacity

Hold and hardness

  • Short hold → slow cooling → lower hardness → lower strength.
  • Long hold → fast cooling → higher hardness → more brittle fracture.
  • Optimal hold → balance between strength and ductility.

Destructive tests

TestStandardAssesses
Peel / chiselISO 10447Button diameter and fracture mode
Tensile shearISO 14273Shear strength
Cross tensionISO 14272Normal strength
Mechanised peelISO 14270Force-displacement curve
TorsionISO 17653Torsional strength
In Weldia

Today the diameter is measured. The model already provides for indentationDepthMm, confidenceScore and the methods CAMERA, LASER_SCANNER, ULTRASOUND and AI_ASSISTED, for a multi-factor assessment.

Quality and defects

Energy and efficiency

Optimising is not only about getting acceptable spot welds: it is quality, stability and zero wasted energy, all at the same time.

E ≈ ∫ I(t)² · R(t) dtenergy of one spot weld [J]
Lobe with energy contour lines and two weld schedules with the same nugget
Fig. 16Weld schedule B produces the same nugget with less energy.

Two rules

  1. Avoiding expulsion also saves energy. The energy used to melt the expelled metal is lost, and the spot weld turns out worse.
  2. Within the lobe there are more economical weld schedules. Shorter times, with slightly higher current, lose less heat to the cooled electrodes.

Scale matters

QuantityIllustrative value
Energy saved per spot weld0.5 kJ
Spot welds per vehicle4,000
Vehicles per year300,000
Annual saving6 × 10¹¹ J ≈ 167 MWh

A shorter weld time also reduces the cell's cycle time.

See: Cycle time and energy opportunities.

Weldia in practice

Overview and roles

Weldia brings together in a single workspace weld spot engineering, shop floor measurement, statistical control, optimisation and, soon, simulation and AI recommendation.

Modules

ModuleWhat it doesStatus
Weld spot engineeringRegistration, versioning, CSVavailable
Sequential measurementNugget diameter weld spot by weld spotavailable
SPCCharts, capability, alerts, riskavailable
OpportunitiesMargin to reduce cycle time and energyheuristic
Parameters and approvalVersioned weld schedulesread-only
SimulationPredict the nugget from the parametersdemo
AI recommendationSuggest parametersplanned

Roles

RoleMain use
TECHNICIANRuns measurement sessions (fast, keyboard-driven flow)
QUALITY_ENGINEERFollows SPC, alerts, weld spots below the minimum and capability
PROCESS_ENGINEERManages weld spots, parameters and guns; analyses opportunities
ADMINManages the organisation and the users
VIEWERConsultation (management, executives)

Access requires login. Actions you cannot perform are hidden in the interface, and the server always validates the permission. All data is isolated per organisation.

Hierarchy

Plant, line, cell, robot, gun and electrode; assembly and spot weld
Fig. 17Physical and logical hierarchy.
  • Physical hierarchy (Project Explorer): plant → line → cell → robot → gun.
  • Tags (Tag Explorer): cross-cutting groupings by product, zone, inspection route, operation or campaign.

Weldia in practice

The application

One route per flow, with a sidebar, a top bar with the scope, a command palette (Ctrl + K) and an inspector docked on the right.

Sections

RouteWhat for
Home (/)Starting point, by profile
Measure (/measure)Rounds; a round opens in focus mode at /measure/<code>
Quality (/quality)Alert inbox, weld spots, overview; SPC detail of each weld spot
Optimise (/optimize)Cycle time and energy reduction opportunities
Changes (/changes)Parameter versions in review, validation and history
Spots (/spots)Catalogue, CSV import, orphans
Settings (/settings)Appearance, account and administration
Simulation (/simulation)Result of the latest simulation

The scope (machines and tags) is chosen at the top and kept in the address, as are the filters and the inspector: a link reproduces the screen. The inspector shows the weld spot detail, the parameter set and the gun configuration. Old /workspace links redirect to the equivalent route.

Weldia in practice

Measurement sessions

A flow designed for the technician: fast, keyboard-driven and never overwriting history.

Scope, new session, measure, decide, SPC, close
Fig. 18Flow of a session.

Step by step

  1. Select the scope (machines and tags) in the top bar and see the preview with the number of weld spots.
  2. New round (in /measure) creates the session and one task per weld spot, in order. It can include several assemblies.
  3. Measure weld spot by weld spot. The field starts empty; the last previous measurement appears separately, so as not to influence the reading.
  4. Choose the source: manual, test device or future Weldia device.
  5. Below the minimum, decide explicitly: keep MEASURED or change to NEEDS_REVIEW.
  6. Each save creates a new revision of the measurement and queues the SPC recalculation for the weld spot.
  7. Close the session at the end. A closed session opens read-only; it can be reopened (resumes at the first pending task), archived and restored.

Keyboard shortcuts

KeyAction
EnterSave and advance
Ctrl + SSave
← →Previous / next task
EscLeave the field / navigate
RFlag for review
Skip buttonSkip the task (no shortcut, on purpose)
Good practice

Always measure in the proposed order and do not skip tasks without a reason. The order helps detect sequence effects, such as shunting, and skipped tasks leave gaps in the control charts.

Caution

Correcting a measurement does not delete the previous one: it creates a new revision. SPC uses the most recent revision of each task.

Weldia in practice

Weld spot management

In /spots you create, edit, import (/spots/import) and export weld spots, always with revision history.

Create and edit

Each weld spot has a hierarchy, gun, sheet stack, X/Y/Z coordinates, minimum diameter and tags. Each change generates a WeldSpotRevision with the reason, which is mandatory.

Import CSV

  1. Download the CSV template to make sure the columns are right.
  2. Import the file. Operations are applied row by row, with staging.
  3. Rows without a match are left as orphans.
  4. In the orphan queue, link each row to an existing weld spot or ignore it.

Export

CSV export returns the filtered weld spots. The revision history of each weld spot can be consulted in the weld spot detail.

Good practice

Change the minimum diameter only with technical justification (thickness, standard, customer). It is the SPC LSL: changing it changes the capability of the weld spot's entire history.

Weldia in practice

Parameters and guns

The weld schedule of each weld spot and the configuration of each gun are versioned, so that it is always known with which settings each measurement was made.

WeldParameter

Complete weld schedule per weld spot: squeeze, weld1/cool1, weld2/cool2, hold, force and stepper. See Weld cycle.

Approval statuses

StatusMeaning
DRAFTProposal being edited
UNDER_REVIEWUnder review
APPROVEDApproved for production
REJECTEDRejected
ARCHIVEDReplaced by a more recent version

GunConfiguration

  • Fluids: water (electrode cooling) and air.
  • Electrode: cap type (e.g. FF16A00, FF20A00). See Electrodes and tip dressing.
  • Tip dressing: programs 241, 242 and 250, with cutter and frequency.
  • Maximum force of the gun.
Current status

Parameters are currently read-only. Editing and the approval flow are the next step of the improvement cycle.

Weldia in practice

SPC Cockpit

The nugget diameter only has a lower limit. That is why Weldia uses individual value charts and lower one-sided capability.

Tabs

TabUse
SummaryKPIs and automatic insights for management
SPCList of weld spots with status, Cpl, risk and alerts; chart for each weld spot
OpportunitiesWeld spots with margin to reduce cycle time and energy
EquipmentKPIs by line, cell, robot, gun and tag
DrilldownDetail of a weld spot or group

You can filter by line, cell, robot, gun, tag, severity and statuses, and sort by priority, Cpl, risk, rejection or date. Bulk recalculation redoes the SPC for an entire scope.

Official series

  • The latest revision of each MEASURED task is included, ordered by measurement date.
  • The calculations use the last 50 samples of each weld spot.
  • A measurement can be excluded with a reason (for example, a proven reading error). It stays visible in Drilldown but is left out of the calculations, and the exclusion is audited.
  • Any change (new measurement, revision, exclusion) queues the recalculation for the weld spot.
Caution

Exclude only measurements that are proven to be wrong. Excluding "inconvenient" low values hides the problem and inflates the Cpl.

I-MR chart

Individual values chart with CL, UCL, LCL and LSL, and moving range chart
Fig. 19A downward trend ends below the LCL, before reaching the LSL.
ElementFormula
Centre lineCL = mean
Moving rangeMRᵢ = |xᵢ − xᵢ₋₁|, MR̄ = mean(MR)
Short-term σσ_within = MR̄ / 1.128
Control limitsCL ± 2.66·MR̄ (≈ ±3σ_within)
Overall σsample standard deviation (n − 1)
Control limits ≠ specification

The UCL/LCL say what the process does; the LSL says what the customer requires. A weld spot can be within the control limits and below the LSL.

Capability

Two distributions: one capable and one not capable relative to the LSL
Fig. 20The area below the LSL is the predicted rejection.
Cpl = (mean − LSL) / (3 · σ_within)
Ppl = (mean − LSL) / (3 · σ_overall)
predicted rejection = Φ((LSL − mean) / σ_overall)
CplStatusReading
≥ 1.33 and stableGOODCapable, with margin
1.0 – 1.33MARGINALCapable, without margin
< 1.0POORNot capable
< 10 samplesUNKNOWNInsufficient data

The process status is INSUFFICIENT_DATA (fewer than 10 samples), STABLE or UNSTABLE. See Alert rules and risk score.

Weldia in practice

Alert rules and risk score

The rules follow the classic Western Electric and Nelson logic, adapted to the lower side, which is the only one that represents a quality risk.

Rules

CodeRuleSeverityLikely cause
BELOW_LSLMeasurement below the minimumCRITICALReal defect
PREDICTED_LOWER_REJECT_CRITICALPredicted rejection ≥ 3 %CRITICALPoorly centred or scattered
PREDICTED_LOWER_REJECT_WARNINGPredicted rejection ≥ 1 %WARNINGSame, at an early stage
CPL_BELOW_1_0Cpl < 1.0CRITICALParameter setting or design
CPL_BELOW_1_33Cpl < 1.33WARNINGNo margin
DOWNWARD_TREND_66 consecutive decreasesWARNINGWear, drift
SAME_SIDE_BELOW_MEAN_88 in a row below the meanWARNINGLevel shift
LOWER_2_OF_3_2SIGMA2 of 3 below −2σWARNINGImminent shift
BELOW_LCLBelow the LCLWARNINGSpecial cause
ABOVE_UCLAbove the UCLINFOChange (opportunity or expulsion)

Alerts have an OPEN → RESOLVED life cycle and are synchronised on every recalculation: an alert whose condition no longer holds is resolved automatically.

Risk score

Each weld spot receives a score from 0 to 100 to rank priorities.

ComponentWeight
Maximum severity of open alerts40 %
Cpl shortfall against 1.3325 %
Predicted rejection (saturated at 5 %)20 %
Trend (series rules and LCL)15 %
Good practice

Deal with CRITICAL alerts first, then sort by risk score. For each alert, follow the root cause checklist.

Weldia in practice

Cycle time and energy opportunities

Stable, capable weld spots, with a nugget well above what is needed, can be welded with less time and less energy.

Diameter distribution with the reducible margin above the threshold
Fig. 21The reducible margin lies between the safety threshold and the current mean.

How it is calculated

  1. Only stable, capable weld spots are included (Cpl ≥ 1.33).
  2. Safety threshold = LSL + 3σ·1.33 + margin.
  3. Reducible margin = mean − threshold.
  4. Conversion into an estimated reduction in weld time (maximum 15 %) and in energy.
  5. Classification with an opportunity score and a confidence score.
ClassMeaning
READY_FOR_REVIEWReady to propose a new weld schedule
WATCHPromising, but with insufficient data or margin
BLOCKEDDo not touch: unstable, not capable or with alerts
Caution

The estimate uses empirical constants and is not yet validated. An opportunity is a hypothesis: confirm it with a validation measurement before approving the new weld schedule.

Closing the loop

Opportunity, simulation, new parameter, approval, measurement
Fig. 22The continuous improvement cycle.

Weldia in practice

Simulation and digital twin

Simulation predicts the nugget before welding. The digital twin links that prediction to real production data.

Numerical simulation

It solves the electrical, thermal, mechanical and metallurgical problems together, usually with the finite element method, which handles large deformations and changing contacts well.

InputsOutputs
Geometry and materials of the sheets, coatings and electrodesTemperature, formation and diameter of the nugget
Force, current and timesExpulsion limit, indentation
Mesh and time stepStresses, hardness, defect risk
Good practice

Run a mesh convergence study, use a time step below one millisecond in the current phases and always validate with a few physical tests.

Digital twin

Design, optimise, plan, produce, evaluate
Fig. 23The digital twin across the life cycle of the spot weld.

Each phase inherits the model from the previous one and adds data: from the generic machine at design time to the real measurements in production. The leap from "reacting to the defect" to "preventing the defect" is made by linking simulation to production data, and that is where SPC and AI come in.

In Weldia, today

  • A simulation job queues a calculation and shows the predicted nugget, the energy, the cycle time and the risk.
  • The current calculation is a linear demonstration formula. An adapter for an external simulation engine is planned.
  • The platform already covers produce and evaluate (measurements, SPC, opportunities).

Reference

ISO standards

The standards most used in resistance welding, grouped by topic. Check the current edition in the ISO catalogue.

Processes

StandardTopic
ISO 17677-1Vocabulary: spot, projection and seam welding
ISO 15609-5Welding procedure specification (WPS)
ISO 14373Spot welding of low-carbon steels
ISO 18595Spot welding of aluminium
ISO 14327Weldability lobe
ISO 18278-1/-2/-3Weldability
ISO 15613 · ISO 15614-12Procedure qualification
ISO 14554-1/-2Quality requirements

Equipment and electrodes

StandardTopic
ISO 669Mechanical and electrical requirements for the equipment
ISO 5182Electrode materials
ISO 5821Electrode caps
ISO 17657-5Verification of current measurement

Tests

StandardTest
ISO 10447Peel and chisel
ISO 14273Tensile shear
ISO 14272Cross tension
ISO 14270Mechanised peel
ISO 17653Torsion

Statistics

StandardTopic
ISO 7870-2Shewhart control charts
ISO 22514-2Capability of time-dependent processes

Reference

Glossary

Terms in English, as they appear on the machines, in the standards and in the interface, with the Portuguese equivalent.

EnglishPortuguêsDefinition
Resistance spot weldingSoldadura por pontosJoining of sheets by localised fusion between two electrodes
Weld nuggetNuggetFused and solidified zone at the interface
HAZZTABase metal altered by heat, without melting
Electrode / capElétrodo / capaCopper part that carries the current and applies the force
Welding gunPinçaTool with arms, electrodes and transformer
Tip dressingFresagemRestoring the geometry of the electrode face
StepperCorrente escalonadaProgrammed increase of the current with wear
SqueezeApertoClosing before the current
Weld pulseImpulsoPeriod with current
CoolArrefecimentoPause without current between pulses
HoldManutençãoForce held during solidification
Expulsion / splashExpulsãoEjected molten metal
Cold / false / stick weldPonto frio / falsoSpot weld without sufficient fusion
IndentationIndentaçãoDepression left by the electrode
ShuntingShuntCurrent diverted through neighbouring spot welds
Gap / poor fit-upFolgaSeparation between sheets
Liquid metal embrittlementLMECracking caused by liquid zinc
Weldability lobeLóbuloParameter region with acceptable spot welds
Weld growth curveCurva de crescimentoDiameter as a function of current
Dynamic resistanceResistência dinâmicaEvolution of R during the spot weld
Full plugArrancamento totalFracture with the whole button pulled out
Interfacial fractureRotura interfacialFracture through the nugget interface
Advanced high-strength steelAHSSAdvanced high-strength steels
Galvanised / galvannealedGI / GAZinc / zinc-iron coatings
Lower specification limitLSLSpecified minimum diameter
Control limitsLCL / UCLStatistical control limits
Lower capability indexCpl / PplLower one-sided capability
Digital twinGémeo digitalVirtual model linked to real data

Reference

Frequently asked questions

Common questions from people starting to use Weldia.

Why does the measurement field start empty?

To avoid anchoring bias: if the previous value were in the field, it would be easier to confirm it than to measure. The last measurement appears separately, only as a reference.

Why is there only a lower limit (LSL)?

A larger nugget is not a defect in itself. The practical upper limit is expulsion, which is a process phenomenon and not a diameter specification. That is why capability is one-sided (Cpl).

How many measurements are needed to see the capability?

At least 10 per weld spot. Below that, the status is INSUFFICIENT_DATA and the capability UNKNOWN. With 20–30 measurements the estimate becomes considerably more stable.

A weld spot is within the control limits but below the minimum. How is that possible?

The control limits describe the natural variation of the process; the LSL is the requirement. A stable but poorly centred process stays within the control limits and still produces spot welds below the minimum. It is a parameter-setting case (see root cause).

I made a mistake in a measurement. Have I lost the history?

No. Each save creates a new revision; the previous one is kept. SPC uses the most recent revision. If the error can no longer be corrected in the session, an engineer can exclude the measurement from SPC, with a reason, in Drilldown.

What should I do with a READY_FOR_REVIEW opportunity?

Treat it as a hypothesis: propose a new weld schedule in DRAFT, submit it for approval and validate it with a measurement session before rolling it out.

The diameter falls and rises in a sawtooth pattern. Is that a problem?

If it coincides with tip dressing, it is the expected behaviour of electrode wear. Be concerned if the recovery stops happening or if the minimum of each tooth falls over time.

Reference

External references

Recommended public bibliography for going deeper into the topics of this wiki.

Resistance welding

  1. Zhang, H.; Senkara, J. Resistance Welding: Fundamentals and Applications, 2nd ed., CRC Press, 2011.
  2. American Welding Society. Welding Handbook, Vol. 3, chapter Resistance Spot Welding.
  3. AWS C1.1. Recommended Practices for Resistance Welding.
  4. AWS D8.9M. Test Methods for Evaluating the Resistance Spot Welding Behavior of Automotive Sheet Steel Materials.
  5. WorldAutoSteel. AHSS Application Guidelines: ahssinsights.org.
  6. ISO/TC 44/SC 6. Resistance welding and allied mechanical joining: iso.org.

Statistics and quality

  1. Montgomery, D. C. Introduction to Statistical Quality Control, 8th ed., Wiley, 2019.
  2. AIAG. Statistical Process Control (SPC) Reference Manual, 2nd ed., 2005.
  3. NIST/SEMATECH. e-Handbook of Statistical Methods: itl.nist.gov/div898/handbook.
  4. Western Electric. Statistical Quality Control Handbook, 1956.
  5. Nelson, L. S. "The Shewhart Control Chart: Tests for Special Causes", Journal of Quality Technology, 16(4), 1984.

Simulation and digital twin

  1. Grieves, M.; Vickers, J. "Digital Twin: Mitigating Unpredictable, Undesirable Emergent Behavior in Complex Systems", Springer, 2017.
Weldia Platform · WikiSource: docs/wiki/conhecimento-soldadura-resistencia.en.md